Skip to content
Advertisement ・ Go Ad Free

Undaunted 2200: Revolution Review

Revolution is Undaunted's Jason X. You never go to space.

Undaunted 2200: Revolution Review

As I write this, Undaunted's future is in the air, with Osprey nuking its games division, who knows what will happen to the series. In a recent newsletter, I talked about how unimpressed I was with the last couple entries, so I suppose it makes sense that the series would end with too many bangs and a whole lot of whimpers. I went into Revolution really wanting to like it, and came out the other side happy that Undaunted may die before it gets even worse, because it turned out to be just another chapter of one step forward, two steps back, learning the worst lessons from the last three entries.

The obvious comparison is going to be Callisto, and I've got good news there! We've left the squad alphabet and the nonsense of nobody knowing what a nail gunner does behind. Bad news: the lesson wasn't fully learned on card readability. Instead of having the backgrounds be a splash of color that matches the unit tokens, the card art is obscenely busy with vague light and dark themes that aren't helping anyone with vision issues. And while reading a (starter) unit’s name lets me immediately know what it does, they were all named by the least creative toddler you know. The unit that shoots things in the sky is named sky-shot, and likewise with the unit that shoots things on the ground. Ground-shoot me, put me out of my ground-misery. I've got more to say about the cards and unit names, but we'll loop back around to those in the bespoke-to-Revolution section.

One of the big selling points of Revolution was the return of Battle of Britain’s planes, mixed with ground troops. I landed between our Dan’s love and Space-Biff Dan’s dislike of BoB; I found it to be a neat spinoff, and all the little intricacies it introduced mixed things up in interesting ways. Mostly, I couldn't just scout spam and laugh as my opponent slogged through with a deck full of fogs. Unfortunately, there's no improvement in the move to Revolution, just a bunch of confounding decisions. BoB’s dogfighting, lines of fire, and forced movement felt clunky, but worked when all the units were forced into the same straightjacket. Units that can only shoot straight ahead become absolutely useless when their targets are allowed to sidestep their firing arcs and shoot at them from their blind spots. I tried bombers once because I felt obligated to try out every unit for the review, and surprise surprise, they're just as bad as I thought. It only gets worse when ground units have to be brought over to an objective by a transport, and then back to the fight. The whole process of just doing the basics of Undaunted quickly becomes a practice in frustration, and just another layer on top of the changes in map layouts and how scenarios work that makes finishing games feel like a chore. More on that later!

Lakers VCeltics. Space Pinkertons Vs. Armed Unionists. Same thing.

I'm not sure if anything in Revolution pissed me off more than the implementation of its branching storylines, because it meant they took the most fine, I guess, part of Stalingrad over the promotion/casualty system that perpetually blew me away. After every scenario, you tossed your live unit cards into a pile and randomly drew one or two to promote, a rifleman unlocking grenades or a scout getting a boosted initiative. Similarly, you'd toss all your dead boys into a pile and draw a few to permanently downgrade to guys that don't have guns or can't move. Combined with the story books, you got some prime emergent narrative: maybe you just unlocked better scouts and the book suggested that this is an important battle, so it's okay if your other unit's scouts get turned into hamburger meat. It also gave you a real attachment to not only your units, but also your opponent’s units. That super scout has been destroying you, and this battle doesn't seem too important, so you can just target its unit until it's a guaranteed casualty and immediately retreat so you don't have to deal with it anymore. That one split mechanic did so much heavy lifting in Stalingrad. In Revolution, we instead get jumps to and from different planets and asteroids, with special units getting added and removed from rosters in ways that don't really make sense. But the absolute gut punch in Revolution was the card changes.

To quote Roxxxy Andrews, where my people at?

One of the hallmarks of Undaunted was that every card represented an individual person, with unique art and that person’s name. It gave the games a very personal perspective on combat that's otherwise generic or abstracted away in tabletop. When someone shot Jim Jamothy out of your hand, you felt the loss (all the more so if they had been promoted in Stalingrad, but I've talked enough about another series entry in Revolution’s review). Even in BoB, although it was a dogfighting spinoff entry, your combat cards were portraits of the pilots; same with tank and mech crews in other entries. So, when I saw that I could only find human faces depicted on the untouchable command cards, literally dehumanizing the actual combat units, not even giving them names, I was beyond confused. At first, I assumed it was just for the corpo police faction, but it's the trade union Breakers, too. I'm sorry, but making people care about little cardboard and plastic dudes is hard enough; why are we pivoting to making our losses faceless? It didn't make any sense until we played our second straight scenario that turned into a meat grinder, and I didn't care that we were trading CMUS and modified transports as long as the job got done. So I look through the scenario book, and every scenario is designed to realistically need at least one victory point from routing a unit instead of controlling VP on the ground. Somewhere along the line, it was decided that the top priority for Revolution was making sure that it was a bloodless bloodbath, and whatever had to be sacrificed to make that palatable was an acceptable loss. You can't care about when your guys die anymore, that would be too much negative feedback, so make them all faceless vehicles. By the time I got to the finale where both sides got to choose what they fielded from the provided unit roster, it wasn't about what both sides thought would play best on the map or their favorite units; it was obvious it would come down to routing units, so the choice was actually just grabbing the best mix of high defenses and large amounts of attack dice. What are we even doing anymore, because it sure as hell isn't playing Undaunted. I could go on about how I hate how extra the terrain border rules are in comparison to how clean the previous tile defense bonuses were, and how they really only serve to make the experience more miserable as you spend six turns getting a mech back into the fight because it's on an island and your transport had to loop around to pick it up, but I think you get the picture. I'd love to sit down and talk with Thompson and Benjamin, because I do think they're more than capable designers, and I'm flabbergasted how the final product here wound up so wrong. Yowza.

Review Guidelines
30

Undaunted 2200: Revolution

Bad

I was pretty sure Calisto was Undaunted's rock bottom, but Revolution kept astonishing me by finding new ways to mess up implementing what I thought was a foolproof basic formula. Sickos may want this to study what went wrong, but keep this box away from me.


Pros
  • I can't just ride scout spam to easy wins anymore
  • Callisto's alphabet soup of squads is in the past, at least
Cons
  • Why are the planes here? they just don't work when you put them alongside ground units that can actually do things
  • I don't care about losing a unit when it's just a card with a machine on it
  • The great objective control game of Undaunted evaporates when you make routing units mandatory
  • Map terrain effects are both less readable than earlier simple defense bonus numbers and a drag on game speed

This review is based on a retail copy provided by the publisher.

Nick Dubs

Nick Dubs

Nick plays and reviews board games to kill time while it cultivates the requisite mystique to become a cryptid that warns small towns of impending doom.

All articles

More in Reviews

See all

More from Nick Dubs

See all
Advertisement ・ Go Ad Free

Sponsored content