Introduction
Five Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic was one of the only Five Nights games I've been excited for since Sister Location. The game’s presentation was the largest driving force behind my interest. My last dive into this universe was Security Breach. I played it at launch, and it was frankly a mess, so much so that I stayed away from the franchise ever since until Secret of the Mimic.
So, why did I end up trying the game anyway? I was largely sold by how much pop the trailer had. It looked like a true return to the creepiness that once drew me to Five Nights at Freddy’s in the first place. I don’t come to these series for horror, but there is an atmosphere throughout every title that is impossible to ignore. It also looked smaller in scope than Security Breach.
With another first-person Five Nights at Freddy's game on the horizon, my expectations were low. A big reason for that was that Security Breach released broken and had an incoherent narrative. I am excited to say that this game blew my expectations out of the water, and I think it's probably one of the best entries the franchise has ever seen. Five Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic, which I will refer to as Secret of the Mimic going forward, is a first-person horror game with more Adventure elements than the previous games. Make no mistake, though; this is still a survival horror experience, and you'll be hiding from the mimic constantly.
We play as Arnold, a Fazbear Entertainment employee. I'm not going to dive too deeply into the story here, but essentially he got screwed over and is attempting to retrieve the mimic schematics from Murray’s Costume Manor. And doing so, we run into the mimic himself and have to navigate The Manor without getting killed. The promise is simple, the objective is clear, and for once the setup is solid.

A world brought to life, properly.
Murray’s Costume Manor is easily the best location we've ever gotten in a Five Nights at Freddy's game, and that's due to the fact that this was a fully realized location, without any bloat. While there are plenty of secrets to find and lots of really cool world-building details, nothing feels like it was inserted just for the sake of it, and finally, everything feels like it has purpose.
There's a specific love for the mascot design that I've always had for Five Nights at Freddy's, and the Secret of the Mimic is no exception. This is especially the case for characters such as Chica, and the pirate Captain, who didn't have a complete suit but were still interesting nonetheless. I find that characters tend to be the strong suit of the series, but normally they don't go anywhere interesting; however, this game does something different, and foremost, the lore provides proper context. For example, we find out who made the early renditions of the suits for Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, and Chica. No spoilers, but although it felt a little ham-fisted, it felt like it was the context we also needed, and I like the way that it fills out the world.
Finally, we also get contacts and nods to major events such as Fazfest, and we get a little more insight into who William Afton is; it's been a long time coming. We also get to see the inner workings of the mascot suits, which brings something fresh to the experience. Seeing these characters in progress was a real treat, due to Steel Wool excelling at animatronic characters and mascot design. I also appreciate that all of the characters that are working in the manor, like Dolly, for example, were given proper context for why they exist, something that the series has been severely lacking up until this point.
The world this time feels a lot more alive, and that's because this game is filling in a lot of loose ends to the current Arc that Five Nights at Freddy's has been on. For that reason, this is the perfect point of entry for a new player, especially since you could technically play this one first to get the context and then properly understand what's going on in other titles.

Gameplay
Gameplay finally feels like they hit the sweet spot. Arnold does not feel difficult to control; at least on a PlayStation 5 controller, his movements are snappy, the camera is responsive, and it doesn't ever feel like I'm trying to force the game to allow me to do something, which is an issue I had with previous titles.
Trying to maneuver around the mimic, a character that can hop into different suits, has got to be the best experience I've had in a Five Nights at Freddy's game. The atmosphere from The Manor is only slightly lacking when you compare it to the mall, and well, I thought that Security Breach was a mess because of all of the game-breaking bugs and disjointed narrative. I still think the mall as a set piece and idea was better looking than the manor itself. Regardless of how the areas look, it is so fun, and so nerve-wracking to try and figure out where the mimic will come from next. The mimic also takes on the personality of the mascot suit it's wearing, which you can really see when it's wearing the Chica suit. This was not only awesome but implemented in an almost perfect way.
My big gripe with the gameplay comes from picking up collectibles and, in general, maneuvering with something in your hand doesn't feel as tight as I thought it could and, in general, could have used some improvements. But honestly, that's a nitpick, and frankly people who are not trying to pay attention to those tiny details are not even going to notice.
As for Chase sequences, they're okay, but only for the most part. Oftentimes they can feel a little lackluster because the environment never had a natural flow. The manor is too artificial a space, never feeling like somewhere people actually worked. I also had this issue with the mall, it’s worse here because of the way that the entire building is structured. I preferred the hide-and-seek aspects of the game much more, because not only did they feel better to control, but it almost felt like the game was made for this first, and the chase sequences were kind of inserted after.

Gathering collectibles, was tedious for no good reason. It's because Arnold can't put any of the collectibles in, like, a bag or something, so you have to go back to each terminal and put the collectible in, and it's just tedious. I think that the developers were trying to add a layer of suspense to the game, but for me it just left me wondering why do it this way. And while gathering things felt tedious, doing the actual puzzles did not, and well, there's not a lot of puzzles in this game; the ones that do appear are solid and shouldn't take you too long to figure out. I could tell that an actual effort was made here to improve the puzzle-solving experience.
Typical of this series, the only way to deal with enemies is running and hiding. This is primarily a survival horror game and should be treated as such. You hide in lockers and duck around corners as still as possible, hoping to not be seen. You'll be able to throw distractions, though, and the design of the distractions, specifically the wind-up mice, was really well done.
Final Thoughts
Five Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic is an interesting title to talk about because if you didn't read the books and didn't play the Security Breach DLC, you're not going to have any idea what's going on. Or I should say you'll only have a general understanding of what's going on. That is enough to get new players to a point where they have a baseline understanding of the world itself and the narrative at play. But for players who want a deeper lore experience, and I will say lore because there is barely a narrative overarching throughout the recent installments, you are probably going to be pretty confused.
And I really don't want to touch on any kind of spoilers in this review, but the narrative is actually very solid. It has a beginning, middle, and end, and a clear plotline for you to follow. Which isn’t special for a normal game, but for once, the narrative feels like a narrative and can be taken in completely separate from the war of the universe. Arnold's character is also interesting, and while he doesn't speak much, he was still interesting to play, and it was nice to get his perspective on things.
My time with Secret of the Mimic didn't leave me wanting more; in fact, for once, an entry in the Five Nights at Freddy's Universe left me feeling extremely satisfied.
Five Nights at Freddy’s: Secret of the Mimic
Great
Five Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic is a must-play for fans of the series and is a perfect point for new players to jump in. Things finally feel like they were made with purpose, and although some elements could have been tightened up, the game was a lot of fun.
Pros
- Fantastic character designs. You can tell now which of the new characters had their hands in making specific characters.
- Amazing animation work and sound design, which come together to make the mimic feel like an actual threat.
Cons
- Chase sequences felt tedious and out of place.
- Gathering collectables is slow.
- Fans who are not into reading the books might feel out of the loop.
This review is based on a retail PS5 copy provided by the publisher.







