Trader Feedback (temporary)

[Blackhawk]

We have a lot of old CG people that are now interacting with a lot of old GG people.  Nobody knows quite who is who, and nobody has any way of checking up on who the good traders were, or on who the bad traders were.  That is why we had the feedback list - which is, unfortunately, unavailable right now.

For your convenience, I am temporarily posting the most recent revision of the Trader Feedback List, roughly a month and a half old.  Nothing posted since 8/28 has been included on it.

Important - this is not permanent; I am not quite ready to transfer the feedback list to CG and pick it up from here.  This is to help and protect the GG and CG traders. Please do NOT post any new feedback here.  Save it until the official list is posted, be it here, back on Gone Gold, or someplace else.[/b]

[Blackhawk]

Welcome to The Trader Feedback List XVII!

Please read the following before posting:

(+#) denotes the number of positive trade experiences. (-#) denotes the number of negative trade experiences. Along with your comments, please rate your completed trade experience. Be sure to include the EXACT Gone Gold name of the trader, and if they should receive a +1 or -1. Rate the trader based on each individual trade experience. Please remember that it is only +1/-1 per each trade.

If you are giving multiple people feedback within a single post, please post each person on separate lines or paragraphs, and please make a note if you give somebody more than +1 (say, for multiple trades with the same person).   If you don’t, I will assume it is a joke or a mistake, and will only count it as +1.

Please reserve this thread for feedback only. If you need to discuss something with another trader, please do it via e-mail or outside of this thread.

Please e-mail me if you have any questions, comments or if you are having any problems with a trade, or if I got your w1eRd SpeLLinG wrong. I will do my absolute best to help. I will also contact the Mods and Admins as necessary.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Fools Gold Traders - traders with -3 feedback or greater.
bplotkin
Kelric Varchilde
TSS

Gold Traders - traders with +10 feedback or greater.
Ace of Spades
Aewulf
akerr
Al
Alefroth
Andy
Andy22
angrycoder
AOE
ArmyOfOne
ATB
Bad_Demographic
Baron Of Hell
bcr19374
bdw418
Big Jake
Blackberry
Blackwulf
Blackhawk
blonco
BobM
Boudreaux
Bushido32
Buster Poindexter
Carentan
Chemical Agent
Chris Genard
Chris Gwinn
Clearcut
cow_cookie
Curtis
da_toad
Damian
Darkhugh
Darkside Blue
Darksoul
Dave Fisher
Deadzone
Devilman
Dobberhd
Drazzil
durwoodx
EduardoX
el producto
Eliot
ericb
Evilekim
Falcon554
Farleybarnstorm
f_monster
FishBulb
Fizban
freyland
Fubeca
Gedd
Geezer
gellar
Glycerine_74
godhugh
Godzilla Blitz
godzy
Goldchamp
Goldenember
Gollum
Goonch
gorham09
Graham
Gratch
Grundbegriff
Gumps
Hamlet3145
haplo1
helot2000
hitbyambulance
Hrothgar
Ibby
IBDoomed
igbe
ImWatchingYou
Incendiary Lemon
Infoghost
Inverarity
Jament
Jancelot
jblank
Jeff Jones
Jeff Nyman
Jeffery Lamarche
Jeremy
JetFred
JMDiller
joeyjazz
John Christian
jorton
JR
JSHAW
Jumangi
Junkie
Kaigen
Karapcik
Kathode
Kehama
KernelVenus
Kestrel
KiloOhm
Knavery
Kratzer
LanceM
Lawbeefaroni
lildrgn
lokiju
Lord Corwin
-Lord Ebonstone-
Lordman
MacHinE
mad_alien
Magicboy
MaxZero
Mersault
MikeToth
MLAW
Mooncalf
MrBad
mrgauth
msduncan
Naednek
Nan_Desu
namretaw
Nine
Noun
optic_freeze
Orpheo
Papageno
Paul Roberts
paulbot
philm
phormio
Poomba
Qbe
Rage_gs
Redfive
Rob_Merritt
ROTC1983
Rowan
rslifka
St_Dysan
sanjuro
scraper
Serlesh
Setaside
SG-1
Shazbot
Siljanus
Simon
Slackerjoe
Slambie
slobro
Speaker2Animals
spigot
stolazi
Sudy Nym
swhitecr
Szgany
TebunkerTheNextGeneration
The_Man
The Meal
tiktokman
Tim Maynard
Toonces
Torfish
TradeAble
trav
tripcrow
tru1cy
trueheart78
Two_Sheds
VegasD
Vinda-Lou
VT
Warning
Whiteboyskim
Wookiee007
x-eyed|mary
xenocide
XMANN
YellowKing
Zarkon
zekester
Zero
Zoyd

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

#
13devils (+4)
3-2 Count (+7)

A
Aaron Conklin (+1)
Accidental Design (+5)
Ace of Spades (+18)
Aidanius (+7)
Aenima (+6)
Aewulf (+25)
Agent (+3)
AgtFox (+1)
AHardPlace (+3)
akerr (+14)
Al (+12)
aledromo (+3)
Alefroth (+32)
Alex2 (+2)
alienhead_69 (+5)
Andrew J. Mallon (+7)
Andrew Wonser (+3)
Andy (+14)
Andy Redbeard (+1)
Andy M (+1)
Andy22 (+20)
angrycoder (+24)
Animal114 (+2)
Annukin (+2)
an0nym0us b0sch (+1)
AOE (+12)
Appaz Knarf (+5)
ArchimedesV (+1)
ArmyOfOne (+16)
arniswon (+4)
Ascendent (+3)
ATB (+26)
Athelbrose (+1)
Austen (+2)
Avenger (+3)
avid_gamer (+1)
Azih (+2)
Azrs (+6)

B
B Dog (+7)
Bad_Demographic (+12)
Bakhtosh Redclaw (+6)
Baron Of Hell (+10)
bcr19374 (+50)
bdw418 (+11)
Beowulf (+1)
Big Jake (+31)
bigearv14 (+6)
Biggercup (+2)
BigV (+1)
Billins (+4)
Binky (+3)
BlackBerry (+27)
Blackhawk (+102)
Blackwulf (+33)
Bladecloud (+2)
Blaise (+1)
Blonco (+13)
BobM (+28)
Boo Radley (+4)
Boudreaux (+36)
Boxcar (+4)
Brettmc (+7)
Brian Evans (+4) (-2)
brotheroftruth (+4)
Bruin_2k (+2)
bsouthard (+3)
bplotkin (+9) (-4)
Bubbles (+1)
Bug (+1)
bugeyez (+1)
Burnout (+1)
Bushido32 (+16)
Buster Poindexter (+27)
Byrns (+7)

C
Calipfso (+1)
Canex (+1)
Canuck (+2)
Captain Caveman (+1)
Carentan (+40)
CelicaKydd (+3)
Certis (+1)
ChaoZ (+5)
CharredBronson (+4)
Chaz (+5)
Chemical Agent (+20)
chicagochris (+1)
Chris Grenard (+74)
Chris Gwinn (+21)
Chris Johnson (+3)
Chronic (+1)
Clanwulfmember (+1)
Claudius Pompeianus (+1)
Clearcut (+13)
Coachman (+1)
Colonel Turbine (+2)
ComatoseTiger (+1)
connus (+2)
consolz (+1)
controlguy (+1)
coopasonic (+6)
Cortilian (+4)
cow_cookie (+15)
CrashTest (+7)
CRAZY (+1)
Crazyhorse (+2) (-1)
croman (+4)
Crowley (+4)
Crumsteel (+3)
CSL (+1)
Curtis (+20)

D
da_toad (+12)
Daddy-O (+1)
Daehawk (+3)
Damian (+13)
dandylife (+1)
DangerBalls (+5)
darkbluejedi (+7)
Darkfyre (+1)
Darkhugh (+14)
Darkside Blue (+22) (-1)
Darksoul (+35)
Dark~Vulgar (+3)
DAS (+1)
daszo24 (+1)
Dave Fisher (+11)
Dave so (+5)
Daveman (+7)
David Roberts (+3)
davidbld (+1)
dbt1949 (+6)
DD (+7)
Dead Ben (+2)
Dead_Meat (+1)
deadzone (+35)
DeFault the Unremarkable (+8)
Depward (+3)
detourm (+3)
Devilman (+15)
Dewey's Monster (+1)
dinkytoy (+1)
disarm (+4)
dkass (+2)
dobberhd (+18)
DocDarm (+2)
Doink (+3)
Doomboy (+9)
Doug Robinson (+1)
DougA (+2)
DPW (+2)
Draco (+2)
DragonFyre (+4)
Drazzil (+34)
Dreborn (+1)
Drifter (+3)
Driver (+6)
DrJones (+5)
Drumfire (+1)
durwoodx (+21)

E
EBatemann (+1)
Ecologic (+2)
EduardoX (+11)
Eel Snave (+1)
Eightball (+7)
el producto (+13)
Elementary (+1)
Eliot (+121)
Ender21 (+1)
Engine#9 (+1)
Enigma (+2)
ericb (+35)
erisquilty (+2)
esofad@work (+1)
Essate (+1)
eton (+2)
EvilAvatar (+2)
evilekim (+44)
EvilHomer3K (+5)
Exodor
ExRod (+18)

F
f_monster (+29)
Fafhrd (+7)
Fake Dude (+1)
Falcon554 (+19)
Faolin (+1)
Farleybarnstorm (+21)
Fishbelly (+6)
FishBulb (+23)
Fizban (+17)
Flag_QB (+6)
Forbidden Donut (+1)
Formix (+1)
fragasm (+1)
Frankenstein (+1)
Freezer-TPF- (+5)
freyland (+58)
Frost (+5)
Frost716 (+2)
Frozen Devil (+1)
FTRracer (+2)
Fubeca (+11)

G
gbasden (+1)
Gedd (+16)
Geezer (+11)
gellar (+18)
George (+5)
Gerber (+8)
GG(Ket) (+1)
giantsfan (+4)
Glycerine_74 (+21)
godhugh (+21)
Godzilla (+1)
Godzilla Blitz (+27)
godzy (+11)
Goldchamp (+64)
Goldenember (+15)
Gollum (+10)
goo2 (+3)
Gookie_Monster (-1)
Goonch (+19)
gorham09 (+15)
Graham (+46)
Gratch (+36)
Greedo (+9)
greeneggs-n-ham (+15)
Greybeard (+4)
Grievous Angel (+6)
Grifman (+2)
Grundbegriff (+60)
gt_steve (+1)
Guildboss (+2)
Gumps (+13)
Gwen (+2)
Gwog (+2)
gx5ilver (+1)

H
Hamlet3145 (+12)
haplo1 (+37)
HappyDog
Hazzen (+1)
hcajandig (+2)
Head (+1)
helot2000 (+13)
Hendo (+2)
Hentzau (+1)
Hetz (+4)
HighTimber (+2)
hipolito (+2)
HispanicGamer (+3)
hitbyambulance (+17)
hodge313 (+4)
hooraj (+1)
House (+3)
howie549 (+2)
Howitzer (+3)
Hrothgar (+29)
Hunter (+3)

I
Ibby (+15)
IBDoomed (+14)
igbe (+24)
Iggy (+5)
Ignis Fatuus (+3)
ImLawBoy (+4)
Impervious (+1)
ImWatchingYou (+16)
Incendiary Lemon (+10)
InfiniteStill (+15)
infoghost (+21)
intangbl (+3)
Inverarity (+30)
IronWulf(+4)
isgrb (+7)
ISMODRED (+1)

J
jadedcritic (+4)
Jago (+1)
Jancelot (+16)
Jament (+37)
James Warden (+1)
jaskerr (+1)
Jason (+2)
Jason Brown (+2)
Jaymann (+1)
jblank (+51)
JCC (+1)
Jebsi (+1)
Jeff Jones (+24)
Jeff Nyman (+15)
Jeffery Lamarche (+37)
Jelry (+1)
Jeremy (+16)
jessie (+3)
JetFred (+100)
JiffyPeanutButter (+4)
jimbo (+1)
JJDyn0mite (+6)
jkinross (+1)
JMDiller (+44)
Joe Newell (+1)
Joel Mathis (+1)
joeyjazz (+66)
John Christian (+14)
JonOss (+1)
Jorton (+12)
Josh (+2)
jpinard (+6)
JR (+14)
js (+1)
JSHAW (+89)
JT47319 (+9)
juji (+4)
Jumangi (+24)
junior375 (+5)
junkie (+29)
JXPrime (+1)

K
Kaddish (-1)
Kadoth Nodens (+1)
Kaigen (+95)
Kalar (+1)
karapcik (+72)
Kasey Chang (+5)
kathode (+17)
KC (+1)
KCJay (+1)
kmmckenz (+1)
Kehama (+15)
Kelric Varchilde (+25) (-4)
KernelVenus (+11)
Kestrel (+26)
killer_roach (+1)
KiloOhm (+24)
Knavery (+24)
Knightshade Dragon (+5)
Koz (+3)
Kratzer (+59)
KrispyKremer (+2)
Krusader (+2)

L
LanceM (+14)
Laner (+3)
Lassr (+3)
Laura (+1)
Lawbeefaroni (+13)
leaf_fan00 (+1)
Lebo (+5)
leo8877 (+1)
LiquidBronze1 (+1)
lildrgn (+13)
linszoid (+4)
Literatii (+1)
Little Fancy Pants (+1)
Locnar (+3)
lokiju (+56)
Lord Corwin (+18)
-Lord Ebonstone- (+128)
Lordman (+10)
Lower (+2)
Low Rent (+6)
LucidSmoke (+6)
Lyno (+9)

M
MAC
MacHinE aka Sam Hell (+40)
mad_alien (+29)
madpeon (+1)
Magic (+3)
Magicboy (+11)
Magnetik (+3)
Mahogeny (+1)
Malichai11 (+1)
Malificent (+8)
Maneesh (+2)
Marcain (+2)
Marik (+2)
Mark Asher (+1)
Matrix (+5)
Matthew Rorie (+3)
Mattsflask (+4)
mavman (+1)
MaxZero (+33)
mb737 (+2)
McBain (+1)
Mcloud 10 (+1)
me (+1)
Mersault (+12)
Metalhed (+8)
Metalhed's Sister (+1)
mier (+1)
MikeR8 (+2)
MikeToth (+48)
mikshan (+1)
MLAW (+10)
mmandell (+8)
moghedian (+2)
Monk (+1)
Montag (+2)
moogen (+7)
Mookee (+6)
Mooncalf (+16)
mori (+1)
Mortanius (+5) (-1)
Mowbray6 (+1)
MrBad (+29)
mrgauth (+51)
msduncan (+10)
Mudfrost (+1)
Mustang66 (+3)
mx1mx1 (+2)
Mycroft (+5)
Mystic95Z (+9)
Mytocles (+1)

N
Naednek (+67)
namatoki (+9)
namretaw (+15)
Nan_Desu (+19)
Ned Flanders (+3)
Neuro (+1)
Nile (+5)
Nine (+13)
Nixon (+1)
noun (+51)
Nox (+4)
nVidiot (-1)
Nydrax (+2)
Nymann (+2)

O
Odious (+1)
Olaf (+2)
optic_freeze (+50)
Orpheo (+37)
Owain (+2)

P
Papageno (+11)
Papashango (+2)
Paul G (+1)
Paul Roberts (+19)
Paulbaxter (+1)
Paulbot (+12)
peace-man (+1)
Peacedog (+1)
philm (+36)
phishbate (+1)
phormio (+67)
Pi (+1)
Pinky1234567890 (+1)
pipboy (+3)
plasticninjaturtle (+4)
Pointer (+2)
Poomba (+21)
ProblemChild (+5)
Psilus (+9)

Q
Q (+5)
Qbe (+21)
Quickfics (+2)
qwoozy (+2)

R
Rage_gs (+74) (-2)
Raith (+6)
Raith95 (+1)
Ralph-Wiggum (+8)
Raven (+2)
Raven VII (+5)
Raven_13 (+4)
Ravenlock (+1)
Red (+1)
Redfive (+17)
rhett (+1)
Rich LaPorte (+3)
RobbieD (+7)
robertw315 (+2)
Rob Eiben (+2)
Rob_Merritt (+22)
Rocketturtle (+1)
RogueTad (+2)
Rookie (+1)
Rookie1549 (+1)
ronin (+1)
ROTC1983 (+14)
Rowan (+11)
Royal Black Watch (+4)
rrmorton (+2)
rslifka (+11)
Rubyeye (+8)
russect (+2)
ryanherrin (+7)
ryanhills (+1)
Ryland (+1)

S
St_Dysan (+11)
Sam Hell aka MacHinE (+40)
Samurai (+6)
SangYuP (+1)
sanjuro (+10)
scholt (+4)
Schroeder (+1)
scraper (+25)
Screwtape (+1)
scubabbl (+4)
SEALZ TomEgun (+1)
Serlesh (+37)
setaside (+68)
SG-1 (+14)
sgoldj (+4)
ShaggyDoug (+2)
Shamrock (+1)
Shazbot (+24)
shifter (+3)
shipwreck (+1)
Shohashi (+1)
Siljanus (+20)
Simon (+121)
sjsharks (+4)
skubabble (+1)
Skyride (+1)
slackerjoe (+25)
slambie (+17)
Sling409 (+1)
slobro (+47)
Smoove_B (+8)
Snuble (+2)
snukadaman (+3)
Solarisgax (+2)
Soulbringer (+2)
SOUP (+1)
Speaker2Animals (+100)
Spicy J (+9)
Spicy Jack (+4)
Spiff (+2)
spigot (+26)
Splooger (+6)
SquireSCA (+1)
SteelerForLife (+1)
Steve (+4)
steveywunder (+1)
stevemn (+2)
Sticky Green (+1)
stiffler (+6)
stolazi (+49)
Strom (+9)
Strummer (+1)
Sudy Nym (+10)
swhitecr (+33)
Sword of Good Trading (+1)
Szgany (+28)

T
TC Weidner (+4)
Tao (+1)
Tazman (+1)
TebunkerTheNextGeneration (+33)
Tech-nut (+1)
The Chauffeur (+1)
The Fringe (+2)
TheGameAh (+2)
The Mad Hatter (+2)
The_Man (+10)
The Meal (+43)
TheMissingLink (+7)
The Nature Boy (+9)
The_Unknown_Bastard (+7)
Thin_j (+1)
Thomas Covenant (+1) (-1)
Thoresten (+2)
tiktokman (+29)
Tim (+5)
Tim Frederick (+5)
Tim Maynard (+27)
tjbish (+2)
TJG_Marantz (+3)
Tokek (+7)
Toml (+1)
tony72 (+2)
toonces (+30)
Torfish (+21)
toxenocide (+1)
TradeAble (+43)
trav (+19)
Trevor Balla (+3)
Trey (+3)
tripcrow (+31)
Trooper_X (+4)
tru1cy (+13)
trueheart78 (+16)
TSS (+7) (-9)
Turtle (+5)
Two_Sheds (+12)

U
Ummagumma (+1)
USAF Medic (+2)

V
Valael (+1)
vballbounce18 (+4)
VegasD (+21)
vegtable7 (+5)
venant (+4)
vermin (+9)
Victurbo (+6)
Vidiot (+1)
Vinda-Lou (+12)
Vortex_X (+1)
VT (+11)

W
walter (+1)
wanderingoutlaw (+1)
Wankerjr (+1)
Warlord_Z (+1)
Warning (+51)
WEB (+3)
Whipsnade (+4)
Whiteboyskim (+49)
Windows95 (+9)
Wookiee007 (+21)
Working Mike (+4)
Worm (+1)

X
Xbox Gamer (+3)
xenocide (+12)
x-eyed|mary (+10)
XMANN (+28)

Y
YellowKing (+68)

Z
Zarkon (+18)
Zaxxon (+7)
zekester (+16)
Zero (+31)
Zicron (+1)
zigdaddy (+3)
Zim (+2)
Zinj (+4)
Zoyd (+21)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A brief word of thanks to Simon and Setaside, for creating the list and managing the first ninety or so pages of it.

[Blackhawk]

Oops - I will fix all the +Sunglasses people later on.

[Sam Hell]

Heya Blackhawk, can you change my old GG name in that list to reflect my new CG moniker?

Thanks!

[Blackhawk]

Heya Blackhawk, can you change my old GG name in that list to reflect my new CG moniker?

Thanks!

Made a note of it, but not in the permanent one.  Remind me again when the official list arrives.

[stiffler]

Will you be merging the CG trader feedback list with this one?  I know that was one main issue we had when we started our own, so it would be nice to have them both become one list.  Shouldn't be hard to sort out since we didn't have that many on our own list here.  Thanks!

Oh, and ericb, thanks for getting around to posting that feedback!  I didn't want to bug you about it since I know you had a lot on your plate, but it was always in the back of my mind.

[Simon]

Under the circumstances I think the GG feedback should definitely be brought over here now. Just a question of figuring it all out.

Duane, I'm glad you are here to figure it all out.

[Blackhawk]

Under the circumstances I think the GG feedback should definitely be brought over here now. Just a question of figuring it all out.

Duane, I'm glad you are here to figure it all out.

Oh, gee thanks, Simon.  :wink:

In any case, watching things from 'behind the scenes', I think it is appropriate to wait a few days until things settle down a bit.  As to merging - if this ends up being the final destination of the Gone Gold Remnant, then that sounds like a great idea.

[Simon]

Duane, your e-mail isn't visible. Would you mind dropping me a line?

[Blackhawk]

Duane, your e-mail isn't visible. Would you mind dropping me a line?

Oops, didn't realize it was off by default.  Fixed.  YGM.

[Raven]

There are two obvious concerns.

How can you match old GG accounts to CG accounts. Some people have taken different names.

What if someoone created an account with an old GG name, and pretended to be that person.

Maybe the records can be slashed, such as this example +14/+5.

That would indicate that this account had 14 positive trades on GG and 5 positive trades on CG.

[Blackhawk]

Actually, looking at your current feedback list, I know most of the involved parties personally, and wouldn't have too much trouble confirming identities.

[Raven]

Based on the mailing address?

[Blackhawk]

Based on email address.  With 100+ reported trades, plus half again that many freebies sent out, I have quite a reference of GGer addresses.  If Rage answers Rage's email, Rage is Rage.

[Tebunker]

Just wanted to make a note, I gave up the whole next generation crap and came back with a new and improved internet identity, however I am still the same old Tebunker, and I'd like to take up trading again... missed the fun of that...

[Sam Hell]

Thanks Blackhawk.
Hey, you remember I did my very first trade with you?
I wonder what games were involved there?

I'm just feeling nostalgic  

[Daehawk]

Thanks BH

[Eliot]

keep it alive Blackhawk. Thanks for all of your work!

[PaulBot]

I am SOOO GLAD to see this list made the trip to CG!

Thanks a bunch!!

[Kestrel]

We really appreciate it, Blackhawk.

Thanks for all you are doing for our community!

[Lordnine]

When and where should I post to claim my trading record?  I was “Nine” on GG and traded sparsely so it took me quite a while to achieve my +13 feedback.