Since I usually don't visit this forum here, I just saw the post today.
I thought the Iron Man Match was really good. Not quite up to excellent, though, and here's why.
First, HHH isn't the same wrestler he was before he tore his quad. He's too big, and too slow, and can't even sell simple moves like a dragon-screw leg whip right. Plus, he's just so damn slow that even a simple corner Irish Whip looks weak, since he is almost stopped when he hits the corner.
In spite of this, Benoit really did everything he could to make the match go, and even though the overbooked ending wasn't really necessary, I did get some pleasure out of Eugene costing HHH the match.
So, overall, really good match, that could have been improved by 2 things: no screwjob ending (ie Benoit winning clean), and a better HHH in the ring (allowing Benoit to pull off more moves than his 'usual' suplexes, chops, and submissions).